Justin Baldoni Defamation Lawsuit Dismissed by New York Judge

In a significant legal setback for Justin Baldoni, a New York judge has dismissed his massive R7.52 billion defamation lawsuit against Blake Lively and Ryan Reynolds, marking a pivotal moment in an ongoing dispute that has captured the attention of Hollywood. Judge Lewis J. Liman presided over the case and ruled that Lively’s statements, which were linked to incidents on the set of their film “It Ends With Us,” were protected under litigation privilege. This ruling effectively nullifies Baldoni’s claims of defamation and counters his allegations that Lively and Reynolds conspired to undermine his career as a part of a broader smear campaign, particularly in light of the sexual harassment accusations against him. The judge’s decision also dismissed Baldoni’s assertions of extortion and misconduct, emphasizing the lack of substantial evidence to support his claims.

Blake Lively’s legal team hailed the ruling as a significant win, labeling the lawsuit a retaliatory maneuver rather than a legitimate legal challenge. In light of the judge’s findings, Lively expressed her appreciation for the support she received from various women’s rights organizations. This victory not only reinforces her commitment to combating harassment but also sets the stage for her own counter-lawsuit against Baldoni for harassment, which is expected to go to trial in March 2026. While Baldoni was granted until June 23 to amend and refile parts of his claims, the central defamation angle has been effectively quelled, leaving Lively in a stronger position as she navigates the legal landscape of this troubling situation.

Summary

A New York judge has dismissed Justin Baldoni’s R7.52 billion defamation lawsuit against Blake Lively and Ryan Reynolds, which is a significant win for Lively in the midst of Hollywood controversies. Judge Lewis J. Liman ruled that Lively’s allegations, originating from issues on the set of “It Ends With Us,” were protected by litigation privilege, thus nullifying Baldoni’s defamation claims, which included accusations of conspiracy and extortion related to harassment allegations against him. Lively’s legal team hailed the decision as a complete vindication, concurrently expressing gratitude for the support from women’s rights organizations. While Lively continues her harassment lawsuit against Baldoni, which is set for trial in March 2026, Baldoni retains the option to amend and refile parts of his claims before the June 23 deadline, though the core defamation case seems effectively closed.